Some things are made of such quality that they deserve a second wind after their first owner decides to sell them via these quality consignment stores. The stores featured on realLancasterCounty.com sell nothing less than first-rate clothing, furniture, household items, and power equipment.
Take time to browse and discover; finding your own “HIDDEN GEMS” in these stores that are scattered throughout Lancaster County and PA Dutch country.
2 West State Street
Quarryville, PA 17566
Featuring gently worn clothes and accessories for fashionable customers who appreciate budget friendly prices, The Fashion Exchange offers seasonal merchandise that rotates quickly. Located in the southern Lancaster County community of Quarryville, you are invited to join those customers who stop by often to browse their showrooms that are filled with racks and displays, featuring an eclectic mix of name brands that are both modern and trendy.
11 Graybill Road
Leola, PA 17540
Located in Leola, Harry’s Fine Used Furniture & Accessories welcomes those with a flair for eclectic selections and an appreciation for decorating their living spaces “outside the box.” Join with those who have discovered the captivating quality and alluring value that Harry’s has become so well known and much appreciated for. Harry’s always has a fully stocked showroom of tastefully staged ideas and motivating inspiration for furnishing your own residence, whether it is for a first-time apartment or a much-needed makeover for a long-established home.
29 South Market Street
Elizabethtown, PA 17022
If you appreciate the high-end fashion of specialty shops but prefer to pay discount store prices, you will love to discover Now Wear This! Upscale Resale Clothing Consignment Store. Featuring like-new condition clothing and accessories priced 40% to 90% of retail, the racks and shelves at Now Wear This! have a continual flow of high quality selections being added and sold each day. From wide varieties for both ladies and men to sizes that range from juniors to plus…there is something for everyone at this hidden gem and something new and different each and every day…so, stop by often!
1854 Lancaster Pike
Peach Bottom, PA 17563
Located along Rte 222 at the southern end of Lancaster County, Peach Bottom Consignment is a welcoming destination for those who are on the hunt for quality consignment varieties at budget friendly prices. With plenty of room to browse in each showroom, they offer a discerning mix of merchandise that is carefully screened. From a wide selection of clothing for all members of the family to a full range of home décor and personal accessories, from antique and collectible treasures to baby gear and housewares…everything sold ensures great value for the buyer and a fair return for the consignor.
1920 Lincoln Highway East
Lancaster PA 17602
Quality and upscale fashions are joined by affordability and amazing selections at Next to New Fine Clothing…a consignment store for the discerning and style-conscious woman. Next to New has two floors filled with a wide variety of clothes and accessories that have been gently worn and always in like new or better condition. Whether you are updating your wardrobe for the upcoming season or buying clothes and accessories for an exciting new job, there is an extensive selection for every preference and taste in style.
7 Kleine Lane
Lititz, PA 17543
From its compelling name to its extensive collection of name brand varieties for the entire family, The Purple Turtle Consignment Boutique has set itself apart as a preferred source for upscale consignment in Lancaster County. Located in the center of Lititz, next to the famous Wilbur Chocolate, this hidden gem provides the highest in quality clothing and accessories at affordable prices. As a store, they have one of the largest group of consignors of any resale store in the area, ensuring a continual rotation of merchandise for the many loyal customers.
3043 Columbia Avenue
Lancaster, PA 17603
Combine your passion for great deals with amazing varieties for every season of the year at Miracles Consignment Shop. Conveniently located in the Western Corners Shopping Center, on the corner of Columbia Avenue & Centerville Road, this hidden gem features quality brand name items that reflect current styles and preferences for children, teens, and maternity. All consignments are carefully selected to ensure they are new or in gently used condition. For growing families, Miracles Consignment helps to stretch the budget in buying quality purchases without sacrificing style.
37 Market Square
Manheim, PA 17545
With an established reputation and reliable base of consigners and customers, Divine Consign in downtown Manheim is your destination for upscale resale shopping. Locally owned and operated, Joyette Kendig opened her shop with a clear mission: “I want to have a shop I’d want to shop in.” For her, this means a unique and friendly shopping experience that is clean and organized, featuring quality merchandise that, of course, is a value for your hard earned dollar. For those who appreciate value but do not want to sacrifice quality, Divine Consign is a store that becomes a routine stop.
1708 Columbia Avenue
Lancaster, PA 17603
With plenty of room to browse, Thrifty Elegance is neatly organized and filled with a discerning selection of items including new, vintage, collectible, and antique. From classy chic to authentic primitive, Thrifty Elegance features a full range of designs and styles, ensuring every shopper’s satisfaction. With a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, Thrifty Elegance enjoys each visit from their many loyal customers who return, again and again, knowing that there is always something new and fascinating to be found.
1243 N. Reading Road
Stevens, PA 17578
Closet 2 Closet Consignment Boutique offers an intimate boutique shopping experience for those who appreciate high quality fashions and stylish accessories but prefer to pay reasonable prices. Just a few miles north of Ephrata, this hidden gem sells gently-worn designer and name-brand clothes and elegant accessories that are the perfect addition for any stylized wardrobe. Everything on the shelves and in the racks has been handpicked and carefully inspected to ensure all purchases are first quality. Whether you are a buyer or a consignor, you will be pleased with your Closet 2 Closet experience!
4312 Division Hwy
Blue Ball, Pennsylvania 17506
Located in the New Holland area, near the intersection of Rtes 322 and 23, The Main Street Exchange is a locally owned and family operated clothing boutique that features modest, beautiful clothing styles, with a wide selection of both new and gently used varieties. This hidden gem specializes in skirts, dresses, layering tank tops, regular tops, cardigans, and a full range of accessories. Can’t make it into the boutique? You are invited to explore the limited selection of products that are offered online for easy ordering.
255 North Decatur Street
Strasburg, Pa 17579
Are you a discerning shopper, always on the hunt for quality and affordability? Then you will want to discover the extensive selection of gently used clothing and accessories at Fashion Cents Consignment. Comprised of 4,400 square foot of shopping space, this hidden gems has over 1500 valued consignors and prices anywhere from 200 – 600 items each day, ensuring there is always plenty of merchandise to choose from. For growing families, Fashion Cents is always a much-appreciated destination for reasonably priced clothes, accessories, and equipment that children outgrow so quickly!
Revolving Door Consignment
35 Friendly Drive
Quarryville, PA 17566
Located in Musser’s Plaza at the southern end of beautiful Lancaster County, Revolving Door Consignment is aptly named for the many local customers and dedicated consignors who regularly pay a visit to the hidden gem. From clothes for members of the entire family to household accessories and living space accents, everything sold is in gently used to brand new condition. Whether you are needing to stretch the dollars in your budget or just appreciate the value of a great find at a good price, Revolving Door always has an amazing selection of consignment to choose from.