Some things are made of such quality that they deserve a second wind after their first owner decides to sell them via these quality consignment stores. The stores featured on realLancasterCounty.com sell nothing less than first-rate quality: clothing, furniture, household items, and power equipment.
Take time to browse and discover, finding your own “HIDDEN GEMS” in these stores that are scattered throughout Lancaster County and PA Dutch country.
707 West Main Street
New Holland, PA 17557
Located along Route 23, the Re-Uzit Shop of New Holland is a must-discover charitable thrift destination for the discerning shopper who appreciates quality and understands the value of a great deal. With 26,000 square feet of retail space and multiple showrooms on two separate floors, there is something for everyone…including clothing for all sizes & ages, books, cards, jewelry, quality furniture, and household items. In addition, Re-Uzit features antiques and unique items via their Silent Auction, eBay page, and Sealed Bid Auctions.
128 TownsEdge Drive
Quarryville PA 17566
Community Closet Thrift Store was opened in 2004 with a goal of helping to meet the budget needs for the New Hope counseling ministry. Since then, the Closet has become a regular shopping destination for those who appreciate the value of carefully screened resale merchandise, including gently used clothing, quality small household items, good books, fun games, and a host of other resale items. Along with supporting the counseling ministry, the store has donated thousands of dollars to other local ministries in and around the Quarryville area.
5602 Old Philadelphia Pike
Gap, Pa 17527
Located along the Old Philadelphia Pike in the community of White Horse, Country Gift & Thrift Shoppe has a loyal following of customers who return, again and again, knowing there is always a large selection of quality merchandise on two separate showroom floors. Items for sale include clothing varieties for the entire family, household goods, antiques, books, and much more. Because everything is “priced to sell,” the donated stock of items has a quick turn-around time, with new items being added to the racks, stacks, and shelves each day. A number of higher value items are sold competitively through the store’s ongoing silent auction.
2842 Willow Street Pike
Willow Street, PA 17584
Quality, variety, and value converge to provide discerning customers the very best in thrift shopping at Main Street Closet. This hidden gem features a wide selection of gently used clothes for the entire family, a tasteful variety of home decor accents, household essentials & personal items, attractive jewelry pieces, and a limited choice in quality furniture. Stop by often because everything is priced to sell and what you find on the racks and in the bins today might be purchased by someone else before your next visit.
48 E. Main Street
Lititz, PA 17543
Located in the center of historic Lititz, Matthew 25 Thrift Shop is a must-discover destination for those who wish to extend the buying power of their budget without sacrificing quality in the purchases they make. Stop by often because there is a quick turn-around in their always priced-to-sell merchandise. Everything sold is in good-to-great condition…carefully inspected before being added to the neatly maintained racks and carefully organized shelves. As a non-profit charitable thrift, Matthew 25 is committed to doing good unto the least of these and is touching hearts every day.
20 E Main St Ephrata, PA 17522
1054 S State St Ephrata, PA 17522
Whether you simply enjoy thrift shopping for the “thrill of the find” or must rely upon it out of financial necessity, you will appreciate the wide selection of merchandise at Ephrata Re-Uzit Stores. The East Main Street Store features clothes for the entire family and a discerning assortment of household essentials including kitchenware and home accents. Other merchandise selections include antiques, jewelry, gift items, and a variety of used books. The South State Street Store carries an impressive selection of quality used furniture pieces, tested & working small appliances, and an in-store book shoppe containing 26,000 titles.
2222 North Reading Rd., Denver, Pa 17517
1167 Reading Rd., Bowmansville, Pa 17507
Second Street features a full range of gently used clothes for the entire family, a tasteful selection of home decor accents, a variety of household & personal items, a nice supply of jewelry, and quality furniture. Stop by often because everything is priced to sell and what you find on the racks, shelves, and bins today may likely be gone before next week’s visit. When you shop at Second Street, you not only get quality buys at great prices…all profits from purchases go towards the support of HOME International, which provides loving homes and caring house parents for orphaned girls in India. Second Street is actually two separate stores, located just 10 minutes apart at the northern edge of Lancaster County, so you can double your shopping adventure!
413 West Main Street
Mount Joy, PA 17552
Join with those who extend the buying power of their budget at Mount Joy Gift & Thrift, a non-profit charitable thrift store that awaits your discovery. This hidden gem features a wide assortment of donated items that are carefully sorted and priced-to-sell. From unique boutique-style gifts to quality vintage pieces, from clothes for the entire family to a wide variety of household items…Mount Joy Gift & Thrift is a one-stop shopping destination. With the color coded pricing and weekly discounting system, all items rotate through the store quickly, so what you see this week may not be available next week.