Logo for Misty Creek Goat Dairy featuring a goat in a field with trees, labeled "Unpasteurized Whole Goat Milk.

About Us / Reviews

Goat Milk Soap, Raw Goat Cheese…

With a reputation that extends far beyond their Amish farmstead, Misty Creek Goat Dairy is known and appreciated for their wonderful artisanal cheeses, all of which is made on location from raw milk and aged for a minimum of 60 days and as long one year.

Misty Creek goat cheddar varieties include Plain, Smoked, Wine-n-Goat, and Garlic & Chives.  Other goat cheese selections include Colby, Monterey Hot Jack (Habanero), Tomme De Conestoga, Misty Lovely, Mist O’ Bleu, Kidchego, and Midnight Dream.  In addition to cheeses made only from goats milk, they also carries blended varieties and cheese made only from cows milk.

Join with those who regularly stop by the Farm for their supply of certified raw goats milk.

From luscious lavender to delightful citrus, you will want to discover the handcrafted goats milk soaps that are available in both liquid bottles and in moisturizing bars.

Misty Creek Goat Dairy products are also available at a number of other retails locations throughout Lancaster County and regions beyond.

Reviews
4.8 Over 128 Reviews
Write a Review
google
Gail Mercado 4 days ago
If you love goats, goat made products, then you must visit this wonderful goat farm!! Amazing cheese samples, all of them were so good!! Goat milk soap is great for your skin, that is the only soap that I use. The owner Daniel was very friendly, such a kind soul, we asked to see the goats and it was such an amazing experience. I have seen goats before but never that many at once. And the baby goats are so cute. A wonderful day visiting Misty Creek Goat Dairy, we will be regular customers for sure!! If you are in Lancaster County this is a must go to place!!
...
google
Sharyn Krogh 2 weeks ago
Just went for first time. Their cheese is AMAZING! Can't recommend it enough. Bought plain yogurt cheese, garlic & chives, and caramel sauce. They also make their own goat milk soaps. You have to visit, you won't regret it!
...
google
BravoSixBoosted 1 month ago
Misty Creek Farm is one of those rare places that just feels like home the moment you pull in. Every time I’m in the Lancaster area, I make it a point to stop by because the family who runs it is absolutely amazing—kind, welcoming, and truly passionate about what they do. You can feel it in every part of the farm.

We love hanging out with the animals, and it’s become one of our favorite little traditions. But the products they make are just as incredible. Their natural soaps are a staple in our house now—the raw goat milk they use makes them unbelievably gentle and nourishing. And I can’t leave without grabbing some of their cheese. The spicy cheese is hands-down my favorite; it’s the perfect mix of creamy and bold.

If you’re anywhere near Lancaster, Misty Creek Farm is a must-visit. It’s the kind of place that sticks with you long after you leave, and I’m already looking forward to my next stop.
...
google
Justin Kahl 2 months ago
Love this store
...
google
Melissa Stutzman 3 months ago
...

Contact Us / Directions

Contact Us!

Phone: (717) 656-4628
Address: 43 West Eby Road Leola, PA 17540

Click Here for Current Hours
Gallery 1
Gallery 2
Gallery 3

(Click to Expand)

Display of Misty Creek goat milk soap and liquid soap with Wonder Aloe on wooden shelves.
Four half-gallon bottles of Misty Creek raw goat milk are lined on a metal shelf. Each bottle is labeled with images of a farm.
Packages of Mist O' Blue cheese on a metal shelf, each vacuum-sealed with a label showing a rural landscape.
Blocks of Misty Creek Gouda cheese are stacked on a shelf, wrapped in clear packaging with a label.
Blocks of Misty Creek Mountain Mist cheese on a metal rack, with labels showing artwork of a farm.
Four bottles of Misty Creek Raw Strawberry Goat Milk on a shelf, each priced at $3.50.
Blocks of Misty Creek smoked cheddar cheese wrapped and stacked on a metal shelf.
Rows of beige maple syrup jugs with black caps, labeled from Somerset County, are displayed on metal shelves, priced at $16.95 each.
Bars of Misty Creek Goat Milk Soap labeled "Rosy Dream," displayed on a wooden shelf. Price is $4.95 per bar.
Bars of Misty Creek goat milk soap labeled "Unscented Oatmeal" are displayed on a wooden shelf. Price is $4.95 per bar.
Rows of Misty Creek Goat Milk Soap bars in Pumpkin Spice scent, priced at $4.95 each, are displayed on a wooden shelf.
Bars of Misty Creek Vanilla Oatmeal soap are displayed on wooden shelves, priced at $4.95 each.
Shelves displaying Misty Creek goat milk soap and lotion with wild honeysuckle scent, priced at $4.95 per bar and $8.00 per bottle.
Misty Creek Goat Milk Soap and Liquid Soap in Lemon Verbena scent are displayed on shelves. Bars are priced at $4.95 and bottles at $8.00.
Shelves display "Misty Creek" soap and lotion in "Mint-to-Refreshen" scent. Prices: soap bars at $4.95 each and lotion bottles at $8.00 each.
Display of Misty Creek soap bars and bottles on a wooden shelf, labeled with prices: $4.95 per bar and $8.00 per bottle.
Shelves displaying Misty Creek Green Tea soap bars priced at $4.95 each and liquid soap bottles priced at $8.00 each.
Shelves display Misty Creek Cedarwood Mist soap bars and pump bottles, priced at $4.95 per bar and $8.00 per bottle, with an illustrated label of a red-roofed house by water.
Display of Misty Creek soap bars and lotion bottles labeled "Goat Milk Soap Milk & Honey," priced at $4.95 per bar and $8.00 per bottle, on wooden shelves.

Our Brochure

A trifold brochure for Misty Creek Goat Milk Soap showcasing various soap options, benefits of goat milk soap, availability in different scents and sizes, and contact information.
A display of various moisturizing goat's milk bar soaps in different scents including Cedar Wood, Citrus Delight, Lavender, and Vanilla Oatmeal, all neatly arranged with corresponding images.

COPYRIGHT © 2026 Real Lancaster County.
No photos, graphic design, or written content may be used with permission.