About Us / Reviews

Name: Forest Hill Leather Craft
Rating: 5

Handcrafted Quality Leather Products…

Located on an Amish farmstead in the heart of PA Dutch country, Forest Hill Leather Craft is a hidden gem that must be found if you are searching for the very finest in custom leather crafting in Lancaster County. Locally owned and operated, resident craftsman Isaac Stoltzfus opened the doors of Forest Hill after gaining 14 years of experience in the leather craft.

Assisted by his apprenticing sons, Issac thoroughly enjoys his work and is very happy to share the finished products with the many people who come through his doors each year. In addition, he sells custom-made leather products to specialty stores and wholesale vendors.

From a variety of belts to a full line of accessories (clutches, wallets, tablets, coasters), from stylish collections of totes, bags, backpacks, and briefcases to tack selections…all products are created and handcrafted with dedicated skill and passionate experience.

Whether you are searching for a unique gift for a friend or just needing a belt that will last longer than a few short months (like your last two), this hidden gem offers heirloom quality products at better than outlet prices.

Feel free to send us a message at…

foresthillleather@ibyfax.com

Reviews

5 Over 94 Reviews

Write a Review

George Beadle 8 hours ago

They have a great selection of belts and other leather items in their own shop. Very friendly owners.

Tanawan CH 4 days ago

Absolutely LOVE our custom bags! ❤️

My friend and I ordered two custom-made bags, and they arrived in 3 weeks. (We live in Boston) We both love them so much! The shop made the bags exactly the way we wanted, and the stitching and finishing details were incredibly neat and well done. You can really tell they put a lot of care into their work!

We were also looking for a lanyard, but the shop didn't have one available, so I bought a long leather strap to DIY one myself. The owner was able to customize it for me, too! I really appreciate how accommodating and helpful they were!

I'm genuinely so happy with the quality and the overall experience. I highly recommend this shop to anyone looking for a custom-made bag, a good and highly quality leather bags and stuff. If I could give them 10 stars, I absolutely would! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Kyle G 2 months ago

FANTASTIC! I bought two 1.5” single piece bridal leather belts. They had a number of options (which you can see on their site) but I just wanted a simple belt with no threading or debossing. They had a number of different options for belt buckles to choose from, but again I just wanted something simple, and went for a brass piece.

Ike (who was awesome in every way!) noticed I was trying to match colors with my shoes, saw that they didn’t have any out in my size with the same shade. He looked around and got one from the back, took the buckle I selected, and had it out in 15 minutes.

It was full grain, vegetable tanned, single piece with a brass buckle. Literally everything I wanted, for $39. Obviously I won’t know for sure, but it looks like this is going to last me a few decades AT LEAST! Very happy with this.

Caleb Comeaux 3 months ago

They are friendly and convenient enough, but when adding a hole in my leather watch strap - they put it at noticeably different spacing from the other holes even though I asked for it to match the others.

Richard Weiss 3 months ago

Excellent experience! I came in looking for a gray belt, which was not on display. The owner then proceeded to locate gray leather and custom-made a belt for me.
Then I told him I was looking for a black belt with single holes all around. Again, he did not have one on the floor, but he made one for me.
I really appreciated his extra effort.

PotatoGypsy 3 months ago

Watched a boy aggressively throw a baby bird to the ground to feed a dog as we parked and got out of the car. Very upsetting to watch out in the open.