We at realLancasterCounty.com love to travel…we have thoroughly enjoyed Italian pizza in Venice, and Turkish style pizza in Salzburg, Austria. We have also tasted the best of pizza throughout the United States. In the end, we humbly determine that the best of authentic local pizza, often hidden, in Lancaster County is equal to the best that the world has to offer! While Lancaster County has its fair share of pizza shops, we are doing our best to share “only the best” as they exist throughout PA Dutch country.
5351 Lincoln Highway
Gap, PA 17527
Featuring fresh and specializing in authentic, V.I.M. Pizza & Italian Restaurant offers hungry customers an extensive menu of made-to-order foods at reasonable prices. Locally owned and family operated, this favorite destination for good eats is located along the famous Lincoln Highway, near the intersection of Rtes 30 and 41 in Gap. If you have a love for traditional Italian, you will enjoy their amazing pizzas and pasta al forgo dishes. In addition to eating in their open and welcoming dining room, join with loyal customers who order take-out and for nearby delivery.
1183 Erbs Quarry Road
Lititz, PA 17543
Committed to a tireless dedication to serving only the very best, Vincenzo DiMaria welcomes his valued customers to DiMaria’s Pizza & Italian Kitchen. Using recipes from the Old World and building upon generations of experience in preparing pizza and Italian favorites, DiMaria’s invites your family to come join their family for a wonderful dining experience. Choose from traditional varieties of amazing pizza pies, calzones, and strombolis. Select from contemporary favorites including burgers, wraps, and sandwiches.
605 Richmond Square, Suite PV103
Lancaster, PA 17601
An authentic convergence awaits you at Ciro’s Italian Bistro, where they combine old world recipes with contemporary style for the ultimate bistro experience. At Ciro’s, you will “experience food”…savory Italian dishes, brick oven pizzas, fantastic drink selections, and absolutely amazing gelato, along with homemade pastries & desserts. Family owned and operated, the relaxing atmosphere and stylish ambiance at Ciro’s is paired with attentive service that captures the loyalty of people who appreciate delicious cuisine in a friendly gathering place.
101 W Frederick St
Millersville, PA 17551
Proven by the test of time since 1968, House of Pizza stands as the landmark pizzeria in Lancaster County. In an age of nationwide chains, they serve the community as a Millersville original, whose longevity is based on the consistency of longtime staff and the loyalty of returning customers who have an appetite for the best in pizza. In addition to their signature pizza, made the same way for over 40 years using the original recipe, they also offer a large menu of Italian favorites and serve 5 different draft beers and over 50 different varieties of bottled beer, coolers and wine.
1376 Columbia Ave
Lancaster, PA 17603
Located in the Stonemill Plaza, just west of Lancaster City on Columbia Avenue, Rosa’s Pizza Italian Grill specializes in fresh pizza, pasta, salads and one-of-kind culinary creations. Everything served is made-from-scratch and inspired by old-world traditions and recipes. From pizza, stromboli, and numerous pasta dishes to classic selections of sandwiches, wraps, salads, soups, and more…if you appreciate fresh and delicious, you will enjoy the homemade eats at Rosa’s.